top of page
  • VSSL

Do Benefits from Joint Replacement Bundles "Spill Over" to benefit other patients?

In a recent article, VSSL Director Joshua Liao led a team that evaluated whether benefits from the Comprehensive Care for Joint Replacement (CJR) Model -- a mandatory Medicare fee-for-service model that requires hospitals in certain health care markets to accept bundled payments for joint replacement surgery -- “spilled over” to individuals insured through private health plans.

What they did: Dr. Liao and team used 2013–2017 Health Care Cost Institute claims for 418,016 privately insured individuals undergoing joint replacement in 75 CJR and 121 Non-CJR markets. They used advanced statistical methods -- multivariable generalized linear models with hospital and market random effects and time fixed effects -- to analyze the association between CJR participation and changes in outcomes.

What they found: The study team found that patients in CJR and Non-CJR markets did not differ in total episode spending (difference of -$157, 95% CI -$1043 to $728, p = 0.73), discharge to institutional post-acute care (difference of −1.1%, 95% CI -3.2%–1.0%, p = 0.31), or other outcomes.

The team concluded that "there was a lack of evidence of cost or utilization spillovers from CJR to privately insured individuals. There may be limits in the ability of certain value-based payment reforms to drive broad changes in care delivery and patient outcomes."

Interested in learning more? Read the full article here. Learn more about Dr. Liao's work here.


bottom of page